KARACHI: Prominent Islamic scholar Mufti Taqi Usmani has strongly criticized the Senate of Pakistan for supporting a proposal that seeks to grant lifetime legal immunity to certain public office-holders, calling it “un-Islamic and unconstitutional.”
Speaking in response to recent deliberations on the 27th Constitutional Amendment Bill, Mufti Usmani said the idea of providing lifelong immunity from prosecution directly contradicts the principles of justice in Islam and undermines the country’s constitutional framework.
“In Islam, no one is above the law — not even a ruler,” he stated. “Granting lifetime immunity would be an injustice and a disgrace for Pakistan.”
He emphasized that accountability is a fundamental Islamic value and warned lawmakers against passing legislation that could erode public trust in the justice system. Usmani added that any such measure would violate both Shariah law and the spirit of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law.
Religious and legal experts have echoed his concerns, noting that the proposal could shield powerful figures from future legal scrutiny and weaken democratic accountability.
The Senate recently discussed the 27th Amendment Bill, which reportedly includes clauses related to immunity and the powers of public institutions. While supporters argue it ensures political stability, critics like Mufti Usmani insist it sets a dangerous precedent.
“The Constitution must serve justice, not privilege,” he asserted, urging Parliament to uphold the rule of law in line with Islamic teachings.
